Scottsdale's Best New York Style Pizza [Updated 2024]

After personally reviewing 15 different establishments, I can confidently say that I have found the absolute cream of the crop. There's something truly magical about sinking your teeth into a slice of authentic, New York-style pizza right here in our beloved Scottsdale.

From the perfectly thin and crispy crust to the generous amounts of gooey cheese and tangy sauce, these pizzerias have truly mastered the art of crafting a true slice of heaven. Whether you're a die-hard pizza connoisseur or simply someone craving a taste of the Big Apple, this guide will lead you straight to the best of the best.

NYPD Pizza

Highlights
Fresh and hot pizza
Excellent Italian salad
Tastes like Queens NY
Best calzones in the valley
Zepoli sundae dessert

From the moment I walked into NYPD Pizza, I could already smell the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizza. I knew I was in for a treat. As a lover of authentic New York style pizza, I had high expectations, and NYPD Pizza did not disappoint.

I ordered their classic cheese pizza, and let me tell you, it transported me straight to the streets of Queens, NY. The crust was thin and crispy, just the way it should be, and the cheese was oozing with flavor. Each bite was a heavenly combination of tangy tomato sauce and perfectly melted cheese. The pizza was served piping hot, maintaining its freshness throughout the meal.

To accompany my pizza, I couldn't resist trying their Italian salad. It was a refreshing mix of crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and zesty Italian dressing. The freshness of the ingredients and the balance of flavors made it the perfect sidekick to my pizza experience.

But what truly impressed me were their calzones. I've had many calzones in the valley, but NYPD Pizza's are in a league of their own. The calzone was expertly stuffed with a generous amount of fillings, and the dough was flawlessly crispy on the outside while maintaining a soft and chewy interior. It was a calzone masterpiece.

And if that wasn't enough, I had to indulge in their Zepoli sundae dessert. These little bite-sized treats were sinfully delicious, with their warm, doughy centers covered in powdered sugar and served with a side of rich chocolate sauce. It was the sweet ending that sealed the deal for me.

NYPD Pizza truly embodies the spirit and taste of New York style pizza. From their fresh and hot pizza to their excellent Italian salad and mouthwatering calzones, each visit feels like a trip to the Big Apple. If you find yourself in Scottsdale craving an authentic New York experience, make sure to pay NYPD Pizza a visit. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best new york style pizza in Phoenix.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Highlights
Cooked over coal
Friendly bartender
Perfectly browned
The Don is amazing
Worth dining in

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly bartender who made me feel right at home. The cozy atmosphere of Grimaldi's only added to the anticipation of tasting their renowned pizza.

Now let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza. Grimaldi's is known for cooking their pizzas over coal, which gives them a unique and delicious flavor. The crust was perfectly browned, with just the right amount of chewiness and crispness. It was evident that the dough had been carefully crafted and left to rise for the ideal amount of time.

I decided to try "The Don", one of their signature pies, and boy, was it a game-changer! The combination of tangy marinara sauce, gooey mozzarella cheese, savory sausage, and flavorful pepperoni was perfection in each and every bite. Each ingredient's quality shone through, making for a truly exquisite pizza experience.

The menu boasts a variety of other toppings and specialty pizzas, catering to all taste preferences. Whether you're a meat lover, veggie enthusiast, or classic Margherita aficionado, Grimaldi's has something to satisfy every pizza lover's cravings.

While Grimaldi's does offer takeout options, I highly recommend dining in. The cozy ambiance and attentive service add to the overall experience. So, if you're in the mood for an authentic New York style pizza in Scottsdale, Grimaldi's Pizzeria is definitely worth a visit. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Scottsdale.

Lorenzo's Italian Kitchen

Highlights
Great service
Delicious food
Top-notch service
Casual atmosphere
Perfectly put together mediterranean salad

Let me begin by saying, Lorenzo's Italian Kitchen is a gem when it comes to finding authentic New York style pizza in Scottsdale. From the moment I walked in, the great service made me feel right at home.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza. The moment I took my first bite, I knew I was in for a treat. The crust was thin and crispy, just like it should be, and the sauce had the perfect balance of tanginess and sweetness. Each slice was generously topped with high-quality ingredients, making every bite absolutely delicious.

But let me not forget to mention their top-notch service. The staff at Lorenzo's Italian Kitchen truly go above and beyond to make sure that you have an exceptional dining experience. They are knowledgeable, attentive, and are more than happy to recommend their specialty pizzas.

The atmosphere at Lorenzo's is casual and inviting, making it a perfect spot for a night out with friends or a casual family dinner. Their menu offers a range of options, but if you're in the mood for something lighter, I highly recommend their perfectly put together Mediterranean salad. It's a refreshing and flavorful accompaniment to their mouthwatering pizzas.

If you're on the hunt for the best New York style pizza in Scottsdale, look no further than Lorenzo's Italian Kitchen. With their delicious food, great service, and casual ambiance, it's a place that will keep you coming back for more.

You might also want to check out the best burger in Phoenix.

Crust Brothers Pizza

Crust Brothers Pizza definitely knows how to deliver the authentic New York flavor in Scottsdale. The thin, crispy crust had me reaching for slice after slice. The sauce was tangy and full of flavor, while the toppings were generously piled on. Crust Brothers has definitely claimed a spot on my list of top contenders for the best New York style pizza in Scottsdale.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Scottsdale.

IL Bosco Pizza

IL Bosco Pizza in Scottsdale is a hidden gem when it comes to New York style pizza. The crust is thin and crispy, just like it should be, and the cheese is perfectly melted. Toppings are plentiful and flavorful. This place definitely deserves a spot on the list of the best in Scottsdale.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Chandler.

Night Owl Pizza & Drinks

Night Owl Pizza & Drinks in Scottsdale is a hoot! This place serves up a spectacular slice of New York-style pizza. The crust is perfectly crisp, the cheese is gooey, and the toppings are out of this world. Plus, the atmosphere is fun and lively. It's a must-visit for any pizza-loving night owls in Scottsdale.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Scottsdale.

Spinato's Pizzeria and Family Kitchen

Spinato's Pizzeria and Family Kitchen in Scottsdale delivers a tantalizing taste of New York with their crispy, thin crust and generous toppings. The perfect blend of cheese, sauce, and seasonings will have you questioning if you've been transported to the Big Apple. It's a pizza experience that'll make your taste buds sing with joy.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Scottsdale.

Fired Pie

While Fired Pie is a popular spot in Scottsdale, their new york style pizza fell flat. The crust lacked that quintessential chewiness and the flavors didn't quite hit the mark. However, their customizable options and fresh toppings do add a fun twist to the traditional slice. It's a decent option, but not the best for authentic new york style pizza enthusiasts.

You might also want to check out the best steak in Scottsdale.

Yo Pauly's New York Pizza Co

After visiting Yo Pauly's New York Pizza Co in Scottsdale, I had a rollercoaster of emotions. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, just like a true New York slice! The sauce was tangy, the cheese was melty, and the toppings were abundant. It's the kind of pizza that makes your taste buds dance. Yo Pauly's surely know how to deliver an authentic New York experience to pizza lovers in Scottsdale!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Phoenix.

Streets of New York

Let me tell you, it was a taste explosion! The crust was thin and crispy, just how a true New Yorker likes it. The sauce was tangy, and the cheese was perfectly melted. Plus, the toppings were piled high with love. This place knows how to do it right. Streets of New York, you've got my vote for the best New York style pizza in Scottsdale!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Mesa.

Joe's NY Pizza

Get ready to experience a slice of the Big Apple right here in Scottsdale, because Joe's NY Pizza delivers that classic New York flavor. Their thin, foldable crust is just begging to be devoured, and the tangy tomato sauce brings all the right zing. Go ahead and take a bite--you won't regret it at Joe's NY Pizza.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Phoenix.

Il Capo Pizzeria

Il Capo Pizzeria in Scottsdale is an absolute gem for any pizza lover craving an authentic New York style slice. The dough was perfectly thin and foldable, the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess, and the cheese was oozing with flavor. The slices were massive and the staff was friendly, adding to the overall delightful experience. It's safe to say that Il Capo Pizzeria is a top contender for the best New York style pizza in Scottsdale!

Ray's Pizza

I must say, Ray's Pizza in Scottsdale delivers a slice of the Big Apple right to your plate! Their authentic New York style pizza is a mouthwatering masterpiece. The crispy crust and generous toppings make every bite a delicious adventure. It's safe to say, Ray's Pizza earns a spot on the list of the best New York style pizza in Scottsdale. Don't miss out on this slicesational experience!

Crisp Premium Pizza

If you're on a quest for the best new york style pizza in Scottsdale, look no further than Crisp Premium Pizza! With their crispy crust, savory sauce and delectable toppings, this place is a pizza lover's dream come true. Trust me, one bite and you'll be hooked!

Oregano's

I must say, Oregano's in Scottsdale knows how to make a damn good New York style pizza! The crust was perfectly crisp and the cheese-to-sauce ratio was on point. The flavors were bold and satisfying, just like a proper slice from the Big Apple. This place definitely deserves a spot on my list of the best New York style pizzas in Scottsdale.